Welcome back to the newsletter that will never stop (even for a vacation!) 🐶

In today’s edition…

The origin story of a man whose name comes up a lot every Memorial Day.

Turns out, there’s a lot more to his journey than most fans realize.

As one reader said, “his attitude towards facing life's challenges stands out as the thing that should be emphasized, even more than his tragic death.”

Let’s dive in 👇

_{TODAY’S STORY IS POWERED BY The Outgoing Co.}

You’ve probably seen the headlines: fewer Americans are drinking alcohol.

But they haven’t stopped socializing.

They’re just swapping out beer for something else.

More people are choosing alcohol-free alternatives like Yapper before their dinner parties, golf outings, and work events.

Why? Because it keeps you sharp, present, and fully engaged (without the hangover the next morning).

If you’re curious, here’s how it works 👇

Fun fact: by supporting our sponsors, you’re helping me keep The Underdog Newsletter free for everyone. Thanks for doing your part 🤝

No time to read now? Click here to save it for later 🐶

“Somewhere inside, we hear a voice.”

“It leads us in the direction of the person we wish to become. But it is up to us whether or not to follow.”

Memorial Day is dedicated to honoring those who lost their lives while defending our nation.

In NFL circles, Pat Tillman’s name pops up every year in late May.

Eight months after the September 11th terrorist attacks, Tillman turned down a $3.6 million contract offer from the Cardinals to enlist in the U.S. Army and fight for our country.

Less than two years later, he was killed in combat at 27 years old.

Posthumously, Pat was awarded the Silver Star “for gallantry in action while serving with the 2nd Battalion, 75th Ranger Regiment, during action in Afghanistan.”

“He is a hero,” said Michael Bidwill, then-VP of the Arizona Cardinals.

“He was a brave man. There are very few people who have the courage to do what he did, the courage to walk away from a professional sports career and make the ultimate sacrifice.”

And while he’ll always be remembered for the sacrifice he made for our country, Tillman’s life – both on and off the field – showed us the power of indomitable will.

Often lost in the story is Pat’s unlikely rise to the NFL.

Born in the Bay Area city of Fremont, California, Pat Tillman was the oldest of three sons.

After he didn’t make the varsity baseball team as a high school freshman, he decided to concentrate on football as a sophomore.

Despite being undersized for the linebacker position, Pat earned a starting spot.

And after being told he was “too small to ever play football”, he helped lead Leland High School to the Central Coast Division I Football Championship.

“Passion is kind of an important word for me,” he said in a 2002 interview.

"Whether it’s playing sports or whether it’s just living. Whatever you’re gonna do, in my opinion, you should be passionate about it, or else why do it?”

Despite earning first-team all-sectional honors on defense, Pat was considered undersized for top-tier college football programs.

Only three Division 1-A colleges reached out to the 5’11” 195-pound linebacker.

But when it came to his dream school – nearby Stanford University – it was radio silence.

So in August of 1994, he enrolled at Arizona State University, where he was offered the last available football scholarship.

When asked about the recruiting process, Pat was honest:

“It stinks. Nobody tells the truth.”

ASU coach Bruce Snyder asked him if he’d be open to redshirting his freshman year.

“I’ve got things to do with my life,” Pat replied. “You can do whatever you want with me, but in four years I’m gone.”

Tillman made the most of those four years, thriving in the classroom and on the field.

After his freshman season, he went under the knife for shoulder surgery.

Despite the doctor’s orders to wear a sling for 6 weeks, Tillman refused.

Instead, he made tackles with one shoulder during spring practices.

He was a top reserve who earned more playing time as a sophomore but dialed it in as a junior.

That summer, Pat shaved his head, ramped up his training, and became a bona fide team leader.

In 1996, he started every game and led ASU to an undefeated season, a Pac-10 championship, and a Rose Bowl appearance.

“He was the most ferocious hitter I’ve seen,” said former coach Robin Pflugrad.

“He would bring his entire body on each and every play.”

As a senior, he ​​earned Pac-10 Defensive Player of the Year honors and helped lead his squad to a Sun Bowl victory over Iowa.

All this while maintaining a 3.84 GPA in the classroom and graduating Summa Cum Laude from ASU’s W.P. Carey School of Business in just three and a half years.

But despite being everything a student-athlete should be, the NFL had its doubts.

Pat wasn’t invited to the NFL Combine and barely made it onto any teams’ draft boards.

“He was the classic tweener,” then-Cardinals defensive coordinator Dave McGinnis told The Athletic.

Too small to play linebacker, not fast enough to play corner, and not experienced enough to play safety.

“Look,” Pat's agent Frank Bauer said, “you probably won’t get drafted, but you’ll get signed as a free agent.”

By the time the 1998 NFL Draft came, Tillman had done everything he could to win teams over.

Even after a grueling private workout with Arizona, not everyone in the Cardinals’ brain trust was convinced.

Late in the 7th and final round of the draft, one scout asked, “Why don’t we pass on him and sign him as a free agent?”

That’s when head coach Vince Tobin stepped in.

“If we don’t draft him,” Tobin said, “there’s no chance we’re going to get him. Someone is going to come in and offer him more money.”

So with pick #226, the Cardinals selected Pat Tillman – the undersized, hard-nosed kid without a defined position.

Some execs weren’t sure he’d make the final roster. The only guarantee was his $21,000 signing bonus.

Bauer called Pat to deliver the news:

“I told him, ‘You’ll make it in the league because of special teams.’"

"He said, ‘Frank, f*ck that. I’ll be starting.’”

Two days later, Tillman rode his bike to the Cardinals' facility to meet with defensive coordinator Dave McGinnis.

“Hey, Coach, I know why you guys drafted me,” Pat said.

“You think I’ll come in here as the local kid, sell some tickets, and play special teams for you. Let me just tell you this. If you’ll spend some damn time with me, I’ll be your starting safety.”

And that’s exactly what happened.

After learning his new position and memorizing the playbook front-to-back, he adjusted to the NFL with the grit and tenacity he became known for.

Tillman started ten games at safety as a rookie.

He helped lead the Cardinals to one of their best seasons in franchise history, where they won their first playoff game in over 50 years.

“We were still having trouble filling the stadium [at the time],” said McGinnis, “but I promise you, when Pat Tillman made a play, you would’ve thought there were a hundred thousand people in the stands.”

Two years later, Pat broke the Cardinals franchise record for total tackles (224) and was named to Sports Illustrated’s All-Pro team.

But the success never went to his head.

Per The Pat Tillman Foundation: “He still drove to games in the same beat-up truck he had in college. He had no cell phone. He chose to read voraciously and develop, debate, and discuss his ideas with eager listeners, family, and friends.”

When he got bored with Arizona’s offseason workouts, he challenged himself by running marathons and triathlons.

During the same offseason that he finished a 70.2-mile triathlon, Pat turned down a $9 million offer from the Rams to stay loyal to the team that drafted him.

After the attacks on September 11th, he told a reporter:

“At times like this, you stop and think about just how good we have it, what kind of system we live in, and the freedoms we are allowed. A lot of my family has gone and fought in wars, and I really haven’t done a damn thing as far as laying myself on the line like that.”

Eight months later, he turned in his cleats for a pair of combat boots.

After committing to the Army for a 3-year term, Pat immediately stopped talking to the press.

He never wanted it to be about him.

He was just doing what he thought was right.

Today, The Pat Tillman Foundation has invested over $34 million in scholarships and leadership programs for active-duty service members, veterans, and military spouses.

“While the story of Pat’s death may have been the most publicized in the War on Terror, it is Pat’s life, principles, and service that are his true legacy.”

🐶

Today’s story was written by yours truly.

If you liked this one and know someone else who might find it inspiring, please share it and encourage them to subscribe:

And remember, there are 300+ underdog stories over on my website, Joker Mag. Here are two you might’ve missed:

Hope you liked today’s piece. To me, it’s an important reminder of what Memorial Day is all about.

If you have a suggestion for an underdog story I should research further, just hit reply and let me know.

Have a great rest of your weekend!

Til next time,
Tyler

🌟 Trivia Answer: B) Pete Rose. Do you think that record will ever be broken?

👀 In case you missed it: This guy turned down the #1 overall pick to try going pro in an entirely different sport. And it paid off.

🎶 Ever seen a modern-day prodigy? I came across 9-year-old Miles Bonham on Instagram and am absolutely blown away by his talent.

🍿 Movie suggestion: Point Break (1991) is a classic summer action flick that holds up surprisingly well in 2026. “Utah, get me two!”

📦 One thing I can’t stop buying: Quest bars. Specifically, the chocolate chip cookie dough flavor. 21 grams of protein for less than 200 calories. I eat one before every trip to the gym.^*

🥹 A comment that made my day: “You really found a niche. Sports are all about dreaming, so your page is very inspirational. I pray that you keep finding stories and sharing them with us.” – Matt Price on Instagram

_{*This is an affiliate link, meaning I’d earn a small commission (at no extra cost to you) if you decide to buy these delicious protein bars.}