The 68-Year-Old Football Player

😔 Sad news: my long-running fantasy football league folded last week because 5 people dropped out.

But I still want to play this season!

So, if I were to start a subscriber-only league, would you join it?

Only vote yes if you’re serious about fantasy football and will pay attention for the full season!

If enough folks vote yes, I'll start a league and send out the invite link. It'll be first-come first-serve, so keep an eye on your inbox!

In today’s edition…

If you liked our story on 59-year-old college athlete Mike Flynt, you’re gonna love this one:

When most men his age were enjoying retirement, he was bench pressing 225 pounds for reps.

All to prepare for an unlikely comeback that landed him in the Guinness Book of World Records.

This is my exclusive interview with “The Golden Gladiator”.

Let’s dive in 👇

_{PRESENTED BY TruDiagnostic – discover how to keep performing at your peak, just like today’s guest!}

Your Personalized Blueprint for Health

What if a single test could unlock everything you need to know about your health? With TruAge + TruHealth, it can.

From identifying your biological age to tracking key markers like inflammation, vitamins, and metabolic health, their reports are fully customized to you.

You’ll receive actionable steps based on your results, giving you the clarity and confidence to make impactful changes. One finger prick of blood, one life-changing report.

Underdog Newsletter readers can save 20% today with code NEWSLETTERS20

_{Your support for our sponsors keeps these stories coming every week} 🤝

Inside the Mind of the Oldest American Football Player in History

No time to read now? Click here to save it for later 🐶

"He looked at me like I was nuts."

Most people would. After all, how many senior citizens ask to strap on the pads and play full-contact football?

But those who might've laughed him off didn't know the real Michael Lynch.

"The Golden Gladiator" earned his nickname nearly 40 years after his traditional football journey ended.

A standout at Bay Shore (New York) High School, he walked on at East Carolina before playing semi-pro football. In his 20s, he landed a tryout for Lou Holtz's New York Jets.

"When my name wasn’t called, I headed for the locker room, thinking the journey had ended."

But decades later, one unexpected moment changed everything.

Michael was at his nephew's All-Star game, held at the very same venue where his Jets tryout took place years earlier.

In what felt like a scene straight out of a movie, an errant pass sailed toward him.

"I just reached up and grabbed the pass like I had been doing it for a hundred years."

That single catch sparked an epic comeback, culminating in a Guinness World Record: at 68 years old, Michael Lynch became the oldest American football player in history.

From the ages of 64 to 68, he played in over 50 games, catching a touchdown pass and being part of two championship teams.

In the process, he became living proof that it's never too late to chase your dream.

This week, I had the privilege of connecting with Michael to hear the full story in his own words.

In our exclusive interview, he shared:

• The split-second twist that sparked his comeback

• How he was able to bench press 225 for reps in his 60s

• Wisdom for younger athletes (and anyone with a dream)

• Plans for a Hollywood film

• And much more

Quick note: I had to condense this interview to fit the email character limit. You can read the full feature on Joker Mag.

After high school on Long Island, you played in college and then went on to play semi-pro football in New York. Then, in 1974, you got a shot with the New York Jets, lining up under Lou Holtz. How did that opportunity come about, and what do you remember most from that experience?

My family knew Bill Hampton, the Jets’ equipment manager, and he had come down to see one of my semi-pro games the year before against the Plainview Jets, the best team in the league, and I scored three touchdowns in the game.

The spring of ‘74, when the Jets hired Coach Holtz, Mr. Hampton gave me a call and asked if I wanted a free agent tryout. Of course, I said yes.

I remember that day well, as I headed over to Hofstra University, I had little expectation of making the team, I just wanted to do the best I could… and I did.

I clocked a 4.65 running the forty, which caught their eye. After some drills, the receivers and quarterbacks broke off and started running pass routes.

Coach Holtz was very encouraging and hands-on, showing us how to come out of our breaks by keeping low and telling us to keep our eyes on the tip of the football as it came into our hands. I did well that day, but so did everyone else.

After an hour and a half, he circled us up and gave us an encouraging speech, and told us if we did not hear our names called out to head in. As sweat dripped down my face, I looked around that circle of players and coaches and tried to remember it just as it was. 

When my name wasn’t called, I headed for the locker room, thinking the journey had ended.

I reflected on where the journey had begun as a young boy, with his brothers, on a distant Christmas morning when we all got football uniforms and didn’t want to take them off.

A week later, a nice certificate from the Jets was mailed to me thanking me for my dedication to the game, and it hangs in my office to this day.

When you hung up your cleats at 28 years old, did you feel a sense of unfinished business? Or did you truly believe that chapter of your life was closed?

That last year I played semi-pro football, I played it without my brother Denny, who was the quarterback for the previous years we played, and he was a good one. He was married and was working on Wall Street, and decided that his football days were over.

I went back out the next year, but it was just not the same. However, I continued playing, but knew that would be my last year.

Our final game was against that same team, the Plainview Jets, over in New Jersey. We were getting pounded, and I told the coach to let the backup finish the game, but I wanted to catch one more pass.

I ran a ten-yard out pattern to the sideline and made a diving catch, thinking my football career was now over…little did I know.

Fast forward to 2012: What do you remember about the exact moment watching your nephew that sparked the thought, “I have to get back out there”? And what were the steps after that to actually find a team and earn a roster spot?

In every corner of America, as a new football season starts, those dreamy games of a distant past are being replayed over and over again by anyone who ever wore a game jersey. And when we wore them, we did with all the elan and pride a sorcerer has when he wears his cloak.

All of us wish we could get into the “Time Machine” and turn the dial back to those days and relive those halcyon times. I always wanted to, so I did just that…I got back in the “Time Machine.” 

The game my nephew played in was Boomer Esiason’s “Empire Challenge.”

The game pits the New York City All-Stars against the Long Island All-Stars. And it was played at Hofstra University, where I had my tryout with the Jets. So, the football gods were stirring it up from the start.

My brother-in-law had a sideline pass, and he gave it to me, and he stayed with my sister in the stands. It was the first time I was on a football field since my last semi-pro game, and it was like sensory overload for me…immediately.

The players look great in their beautiful uniforms with those galactic-looking football helmets shining brightly under the stadium lights.  I saw Boomer getting interviewed and looked into the stands as all the adoring parents, families, and friends looked on with pride at their young chargers on the field.

I was on the sideline as warmups continued when I heard a shout from the field…"Watch out!" As I looked up, an errant throw was heading my way, and I just reached up and grabbed the pass like I had been doing it for a hundred years.

A player walked over with his hands outstretched for the ball and said, “Hey… you still got it, mister.” And that was it. The epiphany.

As I watched the game, all I thought about was how I was going to get back on a football field. That night, I searched for semi-pro football in the Sarasota area of Florida and found they had a team called the Sarasota Millionaires.

I was still working my business in New York, Major Sports Softball, a huge 175-team softball league for men, which ran from March until Thanksgiving. I ran it for 30 years. So, I had three months off every year and headed to my winter home in Sarasota, FL. 

I started going to the Sarasota Millionaires’ practices about twice a week. I would just show up and start to introduce myself to some of the players and coaches. My mission was to just check them out and see if I thought I could pull off what I was thinking, and that was playing for them.

I went to about six games and got to know the owner, Calvin Johnson. All of this time, I had not said one word to Coach Givins, who had spent ten years in the NFL with the Houston Oilers.

When I had to leave and go back to NY, I asked Calvin if I could try out for the team, and he looked at me like I was nuts, but said if I could get by the Combine, he would let me go out for the team.

I knocked out the Combine, and after getting through twenty practices, I made the team.

That first year, I played in all the games and caught two passes, one for a two-point conversion. I was named a game captain for one of the games and was selected as Honorable Mention on the Florida Football Alliance’s All-Star team.

A 2018 news article listed you at 6’1” and 188 pounds, saying that you were bench pressing 225 pounds for reps. That’s something most guys in their 40s can’t do, let alone in their 60s. What did your day-to-day training and diet look like during that comeback, and how did you push your body to reach that level?

I have always worked out, but I was never a gym rat. An hour and a half, 5 times a week, and just watch your diet.

You can work out three hours a day, but if you eat 6000 calories of junk, you will still be going backwards.

I knew practices were not going to be like those Coach Paul “Bear” Bryant had at Junction, back in the 50s. Every player on those teams had been through the fires of Pee-Wee, high school, and college football. So, you had better be ready to ball when the time comes.

You cannot hide on a football field.

How did your teammates react to sharing the field with “The Golden Gladiator”? And were there ever moments of doubt – in practice, in the locker room, or on the field – where you thought, “What am I doing out here?”

I cannot say enough wonderful things about my teammates.

From the first practice, it was all about respect and fellowship. Remember, I had spent a lot of time with them the year before, so they knew me, and when they saw that I was not asking for any lenience in the drills, I earned their respect.

I just wanted to be the best teammate I could be, and my hope was that when I was on the field, I would not let them down. I would get in for about ten plays a game on special teams, mostly. 

I never had any doubt about what I could do on the field. It wasn’t like I was a starter; I was a teammate who could deliver when called upon.

You’ve lived a story of second chances and resilience. What do you hope younger athletes – or even people outside of sports – take away from your journey?

The main thing I would want anyone to take away from this is to chase and live your dream, no matter what it is, and to never get discouraged. This story alone is a testament to that.

I have had a screenplay for almost six years and have tried to get it out there as best I can. I have a great book, which is critically acclaimed, and I wrote every word of it and self-published it.

I was getting ready to run a full-page ad in the University of Texas’s paper, and I found out that there is a movie coming out in a month that mirrors my story.

Instead of getting all bent out of shape and frustrated about it, I just told myself not to look at it as a problem, but to find out how I can maximize the opportunity.

You and I would not be talking if it were not for “The Senior.” I hope it blows the doors off the box office, so they will all be ready for the sequel, “The Golden Gladiator.”

That is what I would tell anyone: never give up, just keep your eyes down and keep grinding.

Thank you for your time!  How can our readers support you, your work, or any causes you care about?

Thanks so much for this platform, Tyler. There is a lot of information if you Google “Michael Lynch, The Golden Gladiator”.

• My website: thegoldengladiator.com

• Instagram: footballs_golden_gladiator

• Email: [email protected]

• Facebook: Michael Lynch

• The book: The Golden Gladiator. It is a long read, but if you like football, there are a lot of good stories in it.

• Screenplay: If there is anyone who wants to talk about getting this on the big screen and selling some popcorn, please reach out.

🐶 

I want to give a huge thanks to Michael for taking the time to share his story. I hope you feel as energized as I do after reading this! Now you'll have to excuse me, I'm gonna go hit the gym…

If you enjoyed this one, check out these related stories 👇

• The Wild Path That Took One Man From Dump Truck Driver to NFL Sack Leader

• This 29-Year-Old MLB Rookie Worked 5 Jobs on His Way to the Yankees

I’m cooking up a very exciting project, and I might be reaching out to a few of you for your feedback on the idea.

If you’re a regular replier to this newsletter (you know who you are), keep a close eye on your inbox this week.

Til next time,
Tyler

Extra Innings…

🌟 Trivia Answer: D) 0. Even though Nolan Ryan never won a Cy Young Award (which is a head-scratcher of a fact), he never let fellow HOFer George Brett leave the yard, which the KC legend did 317 times in his career against other pitchers.

👀 In case you missed it: A ragtag group of bartenders and gym teachers humiliated NFL stars on national TV. But after pulling off the impossible, the suits upstairs said, “Thanks, you’re fired.”

⚾️ What would happen if a pitcher threw a fastball at the speed of light? Dude Stuff breaks it down.

🥲 D2 football alum & Chicago Bears QB Tyson Bagent fought back tears explaining what his contract extension means to him and his family.

🚘 My Halo Bolt has been a lifesaver – I keep it in my car at all times. It’s got a built-in air compressor, jump starter, charger, and floodlight all in one portable device.*

_{*This is a sponsored listing, meaning I’d get a small commission if you buy this product (at no extra cost to you).}